Outrage over The Body may be Netflix's best free marketing
Viewers branded the teen drama 'softcore porn' and demanded its cancellation, yet critics and audiences rate it highly. Outrage may be streaming's cheapest trailer.
AI-generated image
What if the angriest reaction a show can get is also the best thing that can happen to it? That is the question hanging over The Body, the new Netflix teen psychodrama that some viewers want gone and that critics and audiences, so far, rate rather well.
Here is what we know. The series is set in 2004 and follows Catholic school girls through haunting experiences after a Halloween night of raucous partying. It arrived on Netflix with a perfect 100% Tomatometer score, according to Forbes. Outraged viewers branded it "softcore porn" and demanded that Netflix cancel it, as the Cairns Post reports.
The later numbers are more modest and, frankly, more interesting. Per Comic Basics, the series now sits at 83% on the Tomatometer and 97% on the Popcornmeter. The people watching liked it more than the professionals did.
Outrage is the cheapest trailer ever made
We should be careful here. Nothing we have found shows that the backlash sent anyone to press play. What we can see is two things happening around the same time: a loud campaign and a well-received show. Whether one fed the other is our guess, not a measured fact.
But it is an easy guess to make. A call to cancel a show is, functionally, a press release written by the people who dislike it. It names the title, quotes the most provocative angle, and invites everyone else to check whether the fuss is deserved. Anyone who reads "softcore porn" about a Catholic-school thriller either scrolls past or becomes curious. We suspect curiosity wins more often than the angry would like.
There is also a gap worth noticing. A critics' score that fell from 100% to 83% and an audience score of 97% describe viewers who sat down with the show and mostly came away satisfied. That is hard to square with a scandal, and much easier to square with a provocative genre piece that found its crowd.
The platform has little reason to flinch
Netflix's incentives look lopsided. A broadcaster facing a boycott worries about advertisers and affiliates. A streamer is paid in subscribers and engagement. A show that dominates the conversation is doing its job whether the conversation is praise or pearl-clutching.
That is our opinion, not a reported fact: platforms have probably learned that cancellation campaigns are survivable and sometimes useful. We haven't seen any report of Netflix pulling the show or responding to the demands, and silence is the cheapest strategy available. Let the scores talk.
The cynical reading is that a backlash now works like a billboard. The generous reading is that angry comments, however loud, are a thin slice of a global audience, and a 97% audience score suggests that viewers can tell a provocative show from a scandal. We lean toward a mix of both.
What viewers who care should do instead
None of this means complaints are illegitimate. People are entitled to object to content about teenagers, and a rating or a parental control is a real tool. But if the goal is to keep a show from spreading, a cancel campaign is a bad instrument. In our view it spreads the title further than most marketing budgets could.
Our verdict: the outrage has so far not matched what the scores say. If you object to The Body, skip it quietly and talk to your own household about what it watches. If you're curious, judge it yourself, ideally before a headline tells you what to think. And if you run a streaming service, the lesson is probably this: outrage is a distribution channel, and it's free.
No topics yet: start the first one.
More stories
The doomsday joke that outlived its author, and why we love it
A 1960 paper set the end of humanity for today, Friday the 13th, on its author's birthday. It was a magician's trick, and it works better as a trick than as a forecast.
Goob's staged arrest proves fake legal trouble is now a content format
A fitness influencer's "arrest," staged for social media according to police, is less a prank than a genre. The real cost is paid by cops and by our trust in real arrests.
Karl Bushby's 28-Year Walk Home Is a Triumph With a Bill
Admire the stubbornness all you like, but a walk that took a father away from an 8-year-old son deserves as much scrutiny as applause. Who really paid for the finish line?
Jimi Halloween proves the best costume is a tiny, familiar moment
While Heidi Klum's team spends months building a severed hand, Japan's Jimi Halloween dresses people as tiny everyday moments, and it's the smarter joke.



