Castelbajac's tree isn't ugly. We've just forgotten what a kid's Christmas looks like
Paris is mocking a Galeries Lafayette tree for looking like a kindergarten project. We think that's the point, and the backlash says more about our Instagram-ready taste than about the tree.
AI-generated image
What if the most honest Christmas tree in Paris is the one everybody is laughing at? Since Thursday, November 12, the internet has been merciless with the tree that Jean-Charles de Castelbajac designed for Galeries Lafayette. We think the laughter is revealing, and not in the way the mockers believe.
The tree is being judged on its worst possible photo
The tree went up in the flagship store on boulevard Haussmann. It is made of collages and drawings in loud colors, in the shape of a tree, topped with a star and an angel. Le Figaro reports that online critics compared it to an owl and to a car air freshener, and one even called it a "woke" tree. One regular shopper told Actu Paris it looked like a kindergartner made it.
Castelbajac speaks of "un malentendu". As BFMTV notes, he says people came while it was still being installed, before the light, the effects and the music. The store says it wanted a poetic, childlike Noël with a handmade feel.
"A kid made it" is a compliment you didn't mean to give
The designer says he wants people to find the way back to their childhood. A tree that looks like a child's cutout isn't failing at that brief. It is passing it. The insult and the intention are the same sentence.
The reflex is telling. In our view, the department-store tree has long become a luxury backdrop: perfect symmetry, warm lights, a flawless photo from every angle. We have trained ourselves to treat holiday decor as a set for our own posts. Anything that doesn't photograph as "expensive" gets read as a mistake. Castelbajac, by the evidence of this tree, never signed up for that deal.
The "unfinished" defense is half right, and half a problem
Let's be fair to the critics on one point. The photos that circulated were, by the designer's own account, taken before the show was running. The store says the tree is animated by a sound-and-light show. Nobody can judge a stage production from a photo taken mid-installation. But the people who shot those photos were visitors to a public space, not saboteurs. A tree that only works with its soundtrack has a communication problem.
Still, we'd rather live with a risky tree than a safe one. The store itself says it trusts one artist every year, and that this is a bold choice within the store's history. That is the job of a flagship at Christmas: to propose something, not to wallpaper.
Why the "woke" label is the giveaway
Calling colorful felt cutouts "woke" tells you the argument isn't about craft. It's about a tradition we feel owns us. Christmas decor is one of the few places where people expect no surprises, and when a surprise arrives, it becomes a culture-war prop within hours. A tree is a tree, and a colorful one is not a manifesto.
We haven't seen the tree in person, and the show may well change our minds. It might even flop. But the verdict we'd offer is this: wait for the lights, go see it, and judge it as what it claims to be, an installation. If you still hate it, fine. Just don't confuse "it doesn't look like a catalog" with "it's bad." A little naivety in the middle of a luxury store is the least cynical thing about this Christmas.
No topics yet: start the first one.
More stories
Romantasy isn't a guilty pleasure: it's publishing's new blockbuster
A Court of Splintered Harmony sold 1.7 million copies on day one, and the costumes, lingerie and ball tickets say the book is only half the event.
One joke about Mao took La Liga off China's state TV. Brands, take note
Mbappé's offhand line about a "Chinese dictator" meme cost him sponsors and kept La Liga off China's state TV. Celebrity speech is now a line item in every global brand's risk sheet.
Cliff Booth's snub proves theaters still decide what counts as a movie
Regal and Cinemark won't book Brad Pitt's Netflix film on IMAX screens. The window fight isn't about art; it's about who controls the door, and viewers pay for it.
Our Halloween costumes are just Google's autocomplete in a wig
Google's 2026 costume rankings read like a recap of what we were already served: a new Spider-Man movie, a country legend, fresh releases. Dressing up used to be about imagination.



